Loading...
For patients presenting in primary care with depression, adding an exercise intervention to usual care does not improve depressive symptoms beyond usual care alone, according to a BMJ study.
Some 360 adults were randomized to usual care or to usual care plus an exercise intervention. In the intervention group, patients worked with a physical activity facilitator who helped motivate them to exercise (goal: moderate or vigorous activity for 150 minutes/week); they had up to three in-person sessions and 10 telephone calls with the facilitator over 6 to 8 months.
Although physical activity increased with the intervention, the primary outcome — depression scores at 4 months — did not differ significantly between the groups. Secondary outcomes, including depression scores at 8 and 12 months and use of antidepressants, also did not differ between the groups.
Asked to comment, Dr. Peter Roy-Byrne of Journal Watch Psychiatry said: "What this study means is that, if you are in primary care and want to try and get your depressed patients to exercise to improve their depression, it is unlikely to be that effective. This is different than saying that a depressed person, if they can substantially increase their activity level, will not benefit."
Comment
LINK(S):
BMJ article (Free)
BMJ editorial (Subscription required)