Loading...
By Amy Orciari Herman
Edited by André Sofair, MD, MPH, and William E. Chavey, MD, MS
Online symptom checkers come up short in both diagnosis and triage advice, a BMJ study finds.
Researchers tested 23 free symptom checkers — available on websites or apps — by using 45 standardized patient vignettes. Emergency care was required for 15 of the vignettes, nonemergent care was reasonable for 15, and self-management was sufficient for 15.
Overall, the symptom checkers listed the correct diagnosis first 34% of the time, ranging from 5% with MEDoctor to 50% with DocResponse. The correct diagnosis was listed within the first 20 potential diagnoses 58% of the time, with Isabel performing the best.
Appropriate triage advice was given in 57% of cases. Correct triage was much more common for situations requiring emergent care than for those in which self-care was sufficient. (The performance of all symptom checkers is delineated in Table 4 of the study.)
An editorialist concludes that "it seems unwise to substitute self help [triage] for clinical triage right now."
Comment
LINK(S):
BMJ article (Free)
BMJ editorial (Free)
Background: NEJM Journal Watch Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine coverage of the accuracy of medical information on the internet (Free)