Loading...
By Amy Orciari Herman
Edited by David G. Fairchild, MD, MPH, and Lorenzo Di Francesco, MD, FACP, FHM
Two authors are calling into question a recent Public Health England report that was largely favorable toward e-cigarettes. The PHE report suggested that e-cigarettes are 95% safer than conventional cigarettes, and may also be useful in helping smokers quit tobacco.
Writing in the BMJ, the authors note that the widely reported 95% statistic came from just one meeting comprising 12 people, some of whom appear to have ties to the tobacco and e-cigarette industries. Moreover, the PHE evidence review did not include a 2014 systematic review of 76 studies, which stated that "no firm conclusions can be drawn on the safety of e-cigarettes."
In addition, the PHE report's dismissal of e-cigarettes as a gateway to conventional smoking "seems premature," the authors say. They cite a recent U.S. study showing increased initiation of combustible tobacco products in adolescent e-cigarette users.
Other noted concerns with the report: insufficient discussion of long-term, dual-use of e-cigarettes and traditional cigarettes; the conclusion that e-cigarette aerosol has "no identified risk to bystanders"; and the lack of attention to overall product safety.
Comment
LINK(S):
BMJ analysis (Free)
Background: Physician's First Watch coverage of Public Health England's recommendations (Free)
Background: Physician's First Watch coverage of e-cigarettes and smoking initiation in adolescents (Free)