Loading...
By Joe Elia
Edited by André Sofair, MD, MPH, and William E. Chavey, MD, MS
The National Football League's internal research that played down the game's concussion risks "was far more flawed than previously known," according to a New York Times report.
Times reporters examined the NFL-sponsored research, which was published in Neurosurgery in a series of 13 articles. The research omitted more than 10% of concussions, according to an examination of the League's own injury reports.
One reason for the omissions was that at least one team, the Dallas Cowboys, did not report any concussions to the researchers during the 6-year study, yet NFL injury reports document four concussions to the team's quarterback during the same period. Other teams had reporting gaps lasting "years at a time." (The published research based its risk calculations on all games played, whether the teams submitted data or not.)
The Times reports that the studies' lead author, the epidemiologist, and the then-editor of the journal were unavailable for comment.
Comment
LINK(S):
New York Times story (Free)
Neurosurgery article describing the research (Free abstract)
Background: NEJM Journal Watch Neurology coverage of cognitive impairment and concussion in retired NFL players (Your NEJM Journal Watch registration required)