Loading...
By Kelly Young
Edited by William E. Chavey, MD, MS
For patients with meniscal tears and no osteoarthritis, there is no significant difference between arthroscopic surgery and supervised exercise therapy in terms of knee function, according to a study in The BMJ.
Roughly 140 middle-aged patients with medial degenerative meniscal tear were randomized to receive either arthroscopic partial meniscectomy without postoperative rehabilitation or neuromuscular and strength exercise sessions over 12 weeks.
At 2 years’ follow-up, there was no significant difference between groups in patient-reported pain, symptoms, function, and knee-related quality of life. Roughly 80% of patients in both groups had a clinically meaningful improvement. The exercise group did have greater improvements in muscle strength and in the 6-minute timed hop test at 12 months.
Editorialists call these results, “the latest nail into what should be a sealing coffin” for this surgery.
Comment
LINK(S):
The BMJ article (Free)
The BMJ editorial (Free)
Background: NEJM Journal Watch General Medicine coverage of surgery for meniscal tears (Free)