Loading...
By Amy Orciari Herman
Edited by David G. Fairchild, MD, MPH, and Jaye Elizabeth Hefner, MD
Surgery for Achilles rupture is associated with a decreased risk for re-rupture — but an increased risk for complications — according to a meta-analysis in The BMJ.
The analysis included 10 randomized trials and 19 observational studies in which nearly 16,000 patients underwent surgery for Achilles rupture or received nonoperative treatment. Re-rupture occurred in 2.3% of patients in the operative group versus 3.9% in the nonoperative group. Complications, meanwhile, occurred in 4.9% versus 1.6%, respectively. The most common complication with surgery was infection; the most common with nonoperative treatment was deep-venous thrombosis. Return to sports or work did not seem to differ between the groups.
Editorialists say, "The clinical relevance [of the differences] is questionable." They note that "non-operative management ... is apparently cheaper and avoids surgical complications," but "less invasive surgical repair techniques performed under local anaesthesia in outpatients can be safe and effective." Therefore, "a personalized approach incorporating fully informed shared decision making remains essential."
Comment
LINK(S):
The BMJ article (Free)
The BMJ editorial (Subscription required)
The BMJ opinion (Free)
Background: NEJM Journal Watch Infectious Diseases coverage of risk for Achilles rupture with fluoroquinolone use (Your NEJM Journal Watch registration required)