Loading...
By Kelly Young
Edited by André Sofair, MD, MPH, and William E. Chavey, MD, MS
This week, MMWR offers several studies that look at the effectiveness of quarantine policies and at COVID-19 spread and control on college campuses.
First, a study examined the time from quarantine to positive SARS-CoV-2 test in college athletes. More of the 1800 quarantined athletes had exposures from social gatherings (41%) or roommates (32%) than from their respective sports (13%). Of the 25% who tested positive during quarantine, the mean time until positive test result was 3.8 days from the start of quarantine. The probability of having a positive test fell to less than 5% after day 10. The authors say the results support current CDC guidance for testing options to shorten quarantine.
Along these same lines — though not in a college setting — another MMWR study noted that in Vermont, a third of contacts who tested positive on PCR 7 days after exposure were asymptomatic. (Vermont's policy is to shorten quarantine time for asymptomatic contacts who test negative on day 7.) None of the people who were negative on day 7 tested positive during days 8–14. The authors write: "Allowing asymptomatic persons to shorten quarantine with a negative test at day 7 or later has not been demonstrated to result in transmission of SARS-CoV-2, indicating that the policy has been effective."
Finally, a study found that counties with large colleges that opened with in-person instruction in fall 2020 saw a 56% increase in mean COVID-19 incidence in the 21 days before through 21 days after classes began (increasing from 15 to 24 cases per 100,000). The percentage of positive tests also increased. In contrast, counties with colleges that began with remote instruction saw an 18% decline in COVID-19 during a similar timeframe, and counties without large colleges had a 6% decline.
Comment
LINK(S):
MMWR article on athlete quarantines (Free)
MMWR article on Vermont quarantine (Free)
MMWR article on in-person instruction at colleges (Free)
NEJM Journal Watch COVID-19 page (Free)
NEJM COVID-19 page (Free)